Skip to Content
Resize Text:      A A
Home  /  Newsroom  /  Headlines
Jun 13, 2010   |  Bozeman Daily Chronicle

A deal’s a deal.

Bozeman Daily Chronicle

By: Editorial

That’s the message Montana Sen. Jon Tester has for the U.S. Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee. And, in reality, he has little choice.

Tester’s forest bill came out of a delicate compromise among diverse forest user groups. It would create some 600,000 acres of wilderness — mostly here in Southwest Montana. But it would also set aside areas for motorized recreation and require the logging of 10,000 acres of forest in each of the next 10 years.

The diverse bill was crafted by representatives of wilderness advocates, motorized recreationists and timber industry representatives. And that mix has made for widespread — if fragile — support for the bill.

But now members of the Senate committee are proposing to strip the logging and motorized recreation out of the bill and just establish the wilderness areas.

Senate memories are apparently not all that long. It’s been more than 20 years since the Montana congressional delegation came close to passing wilderness-protection legislation. That measure designated wilderness and wilderness only — more than 5 million acres around the state — and made it through the Democrat-controlled House and Senate only to be vetoed by then-Republican President Ronald Reagan, who had absolutely no stake in the Montana wilderness politics.

Such is the divisive nature of Montana wilderness politics. Even an act of Congress is not enough to resolve the issue. The veto essentially stalled any progress on the issue for more than two decades.

Tester’s bill is an experiment of sorts. It only deals with a portion of the state, and it does a whole lot more than just designate wilderness. It includes something meaningful for a range of forest users — not just wilderness advocates. And that is what has created a consensus of support that rises above the politics of Washington.

If the Senate committee strips out all but the wilderness designations, as it is proposing to do, it will self-destruct. Support for the bill will crumble and it is doomed. It’s that simple.

Tester has said he will come up with a counter-offer to the committee’s proposal this week, but he will not be able to stray far from the original bill, or opposition will begin lining up — and it will be formidable.

If Tester can hold this measure together and move the Montana wilderness debate off the dime, it may offer a template for resolving this decades-old conundrum for the entire state.

Office Contact Information

Senator Tester's Montana staff serves the state from offices in Billings, Bozeman, Butte, Great Falls, Helena, Kalispell, and Missoula. Please bring your concerns with federal agencies, academy nominations, and other situations to one of these Montana offices.

Billings

Judge Jameson Federal Building
2900 4th Ave N, Suite 201
Billings, MT 59101
Phone: (406) 252-0550
Fax: (406) 252-7768

Bozeman

Avant Courier Building
1 E Main Street, Suite 202
Bozeman, MT 59715
Phone: (406) 586-4450
Fax: (406) 586-7647

Butte

Silver Bow Center
125 W Granite, Suite 200
Butte, MT 59701
Phone: (406) 723-3277
Fax: (406) 782-4717

Great Falls

119 1st Avenue N, Suite 102
Great Falls, MT 59401
Phone: (406) 452-9585
Fax: (406) 452-9586

Helena

Capital One Center
208 N Montana Avenue, Suite 202
Helena, MT 59601
Phone: (406) 449-5401
Fax: (406) 449-5462

Kalispell

8 Third Street E
Kalispell, MT 59901
Phone: (406) 257-3360
Fax: (406) 257-3974

Missoula

130 W Front St.
Missoula, MT 59802
Phone: (406) 728-3003
Fax: (406) 728-2193

Home   |   Meet Jon   |   Services   |   Newsroom   |   Legislation   |   Contact   |   Privacy